Black Hills Knowledge Netowork

A civil trial arising from an incident in Pine Ridge should not be tried before jurors from a different county, the state's high court has ruled.
A civil trial arising from an incident in Pine Ridge should not be tried before jurors from a different county, the state's high court has ruled.
BHKN photo/Chelsea Gortmaker
November 9, 2015

Jurors In Pine Ridge Case Should Come From Oglala Lakota County Says SD Supreme Court

Jurors from neighboring Fall River County should not hear a civil case arising out of an incident that occurred in Pine Ridge, the South Dakota Supreme Court decided when it unanimously ruled to reverse a lower court's standing order to not draw jurors who are tribal members living in Oglala Lakota County.

South Dakota Public Radio reports that a standing order in the Seventh Circuit Court to empanel Fall River County jurors in all cases from Oglala Lakota County (formerly Shannon County) amounted to a change of venue and was unconstitutional. 

Trials for state cases arising out of Oglala Lakota County are held at the Fall River County courthouse in Hot Springs because there is not a courthouse in Oglala Lakota County. A lawyer argued to the court that because the state lacks jurisdiction to hold tribal members in contempt of court for failing to report for jury duty, tribal members are unlikely to serve as jurors. Those who would report would likely do so because of a bias in the case, he argued.

During oral arguments, excerpted in the SDPB report, the chief justice replied: "Wow." Another justice said the standing order "presumes tribal members aren't going to appear out of civic duty." Another justice asked, "How do you know until you try?"

Read more about the courts on the Black Hills Knowledge Network.


Related items

  • Rural Residents Receive Broadband Access Via Connect SD Initiative

    The Connect South Dakota initiative, a $5 million state-funded grant program proposed by Governor Kristi Noem in her State of the State and budget address…
  • Rapid City Organization Celebrates Women’s Equality Day

    In 1920, Congress certified the 19th Amendment, giving women in the United States the right to vote – in 1971, Congress declared that August 26th…
  • Hunter Roberts Named SD DENR Secretary

    Republican Governor Kristi Noem announced Tuesday that Hunter Roberts, former policy adviser and current Department of Labor deputy secretary, has been named Secretary of South…

Get Involved!

  • Need more information? Rapid City Public Library associates are standing by to answer your questions! Ask away in the box below during business hours for live feedback.

    For more on this feature, click here.

  • bhkn donate

    Enjoy our work? Donate today to ensure that community members will have access to our wealth of news, history, and data for years to come.

  • 211 logoDid this post inspire you to get involved? Visit our partner 211's Volunteer Database to find volunteer opportunities in your community.

525 University Loop, Suite 202
Rapid City, SD 57701
(605) 716-0058   [email protected]